Choose your text size:  A   A   A   

 
US Senator Orrin Hatch
June 29th, 2009   Media Contact(s): Mark Eddington and Andrea Saul, 202-224-5251
Printable Version
HATCH STATEMENT ON SUPREME COURT REVERSING SOTOMAYOR FIREFIGHTERS DECISION
 
WASHINGTON – U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), a longtime member and former chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, made the following statement today after the Supreme Court overturned a decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in which Supreme Court nominee Judge Sonia Sotomayor participated:

“The Supreme Court today correctly held that race-based employment decisions must be justified by facts, not fear,” said Hatch. “These firefighters, who worked long and hard for it, were denied the chance for promotion because of their race.

“In the twenty-first century, race discrimination requires more justification than the fear of being sued. The Second Circuit should have recognized the serious and unique issues this case raised and given it the thorough treatment it deserved.”

The appeals court, in a very short per curiam opinion, upheld the decision by New Haven, Connecticut, to disregard results of a firefighter promotion exam because racial minorities did not score highly enough. Today, the Supreme Court held that discarding the results of a fairly designed and administered employment test solely because of the racial distribution of the result violates Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

 
###
 
 
 
 
 
June 2009 News Items
Radio Clip icon Radio Clip | Television Clip icon Television Clip
29th - current News Item 
25th  In Case You Missed It: Hatch on America’s Morning News [ listen to Radio Clip ]
24th  Hatch Sends Message to Health Care Tea Party Participants
24th  Senate Western Caucus Launched with Introduction of Comprehensive Energy Bill
24th  Hatch: Sotomayor’s Rulings on Second Amendment Cases Troubling [ listen to Radio Clip ] [ view Television Clip ]
22nd  Hatch, Lincoln, Corker Introduce Amendment to Stop Recycling of TARP Money
19th  Hatch Welcomes Bipartisan Opposition to International Tax Proposals
19th  Hatch Frustrated With Lack of Bipartisan Progress on Healthcare Reform
18th  Hatch Offers Amendment to Reduce Medical Malpractice and Control Costs
18th  Enzi & Hatch Question President’s Firing of Inspector General at National and Community Service Corporation
18th  Hatch Urges Obama To Protect Intellectual Property Rights
17th  Hatch Blasts Democrats’ Affordable Health Choices Act
16th  Hatch, Bennett Ask U.S. Attorney General to Look Into San Juan Raid
15th  President's Flawed Health Care Process Hits First Major Snag
11th  Hatch, Lincoln Introduce Bill to Stop Recycling of TARP Money
10th  Hatch: State Secrets Protection Act a Threat to National Security
10th  In Case You Missed It: Don't Close Guantanamo
  9th  Hatch Blasts Obama's plan for Government-run Healthcare
  9th  Hatch: More Time Needed for Sotomayor Confirmation
  8th  Hatch and Republican Finance Committee Members Implore Obama: No Government-Run Healthcare Plan
  8th  Hatch Introduces Tax Bill to Provide a Boost to Research-based Companies
  8th  In Case You Mised It: Hatch Talks to 'Fox News' about Obama's Healthcare Plan
  8th  In Case You Missed It: Fully Funding The Patent Office Is A Key To Economic Recovery
  2nd  Hatch Statement on Meeting with Judge Sotomayor
  1st  In Case You Missed It: Senate Determines Judges
 
 

104 Hart Office Building - Washington, DC 20510 - Tel: (202) 224-5251 - Fax: (202) 224-6331